THE PEOPLE’S ADVOCATE AND THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF ROMANIA – ENTITIES INVOLVED IN THE AFFIRMATION OF FREEDOM AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN CRISIS SITUATIONS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10419672Keywords:
People’s Advocate, Constitutional Court of Romania, health crisis, economic crisis, human rights, education, digitizationAbstract
The People’s Advocate and the Constitutional Court of Romania – Entities Involved in the Affirmation of Freedom and Human Rights in Crisis Situations.
The paper includes a brief presentation of the research results regarding the possibility of two entities with a special legal status in Romania - the People’s Advocate and the Constitutional Court - to participate in the management of internal social crises that have arisen against the background of world crises, with special regard to the affirmation of freedom and human rights in crisis situations. We will identify the limits of action and assess the possibility of expanding the competence of these entities or supplementing the action mechanisms at their disposal. The role and action mechanisms of the People’s Advocate, as an autonomous public authority, are analyzed both from a legal point of view and from the point of view of its practice in several social crisis situations manifested in Romania as a result of the existence of crisis situations at the global level. Starting from the legal force of the decisions of the Constitutional Court of Romania, its jurisprudence was analyzed with an impact on the management of certain crisis situations, especially in the field of asserting freedom and human rights. Structurally, the paper contains eight headings. In the first heading we have presented the reasons of our research. The second heading analyzes the concept of crisis, emphasizing that there is also a positive side to crisis situations, consisting in the fact that most of the time they determine progress by forcing people to find solutions out of crisis, occasion that also results in the improvement of social relations, or of concepts. The third heading presents the role of the People’s Advocate, his action mechanisms criticizing the limits of action within which he is required to work. The fourth heading includes a critical presentation of the regulations regarding the competence and mode of action of the Constitutional Court of Romania. The fifth heading is a case study on the involvement of the People’s Advocate and the Constitutional Court in the management of the crisis caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, and the sixth heading includes the case study about Ukrainian refugees. In the seventh heading, we answer to the following questions: a) Can People’s Advocate and the Constitutional Court of Romania contribute to the prevention of the violation of freedom and human rights through actions that strengthen the role of education in society, starting from the premise that the level of education is the first element that can mitigate or increase a state of crisis? b) Is digitization a tool that can prevent crises? The paper concludes with de lege ferenda proposals.
References
• *** Dicţionarul explicativ al limbii române/Explanatory dictionary of the Romanian language, Universul enciclopedic, Bucharest, 1998.
• ALEXANDRU, I., Criza administraţiei/Crisis of administration, AllBeck, Bucharest, 2001.
• MURARU, I., “Rolul Avocatului Poporului în România/The Role of the People’s Advocate in Romania” in the volume Alina-Livia Nicu-coordinator, Avocatul Poporului mijloc de control al cetățenilor asupra administrației publice/People’s Advocate means of citizens’ control over public Administration, Ed. Universitaria, Craiova, 2006, pp. 25-29.
• MICHAUD, G. et Marc, E., Vers une science des civilizations/Towards a science of civilizations, Ed. Complexe, Bruxelles, 1981.
• NICU, A.-L., Aspecte privind reglementarea funcției publice în România sub presiunea crizei economice/Aspects regarding the regulation of the public function in Romania under the pressure of the economic crisis, in the volume Emilian M. Dobrescu - coordinator, Cartea crizelor. O privire optimistă / The book of crises. An optimistic view, Wolters Kluver Publishing House, 2010, pp. 218-240.
Web sources :
• Angel, O. “Imagini tulburătoare la Vama Siret. Sute de refugiaţi ucraineni, aşteptaţi cu gogoşi calde şi camioane pline cu alimente. Peste 4000 de oferte de cazare gratuită/Disturbing images at Siret Customs. Hundreds of Ukrainian refugees, waiting with warm donuts and trucks full of food. Over 4000 free accommodation offers”, RomâniaTV.net [online], 25 February 2022, 18:38. Available at: https://www.romaniatv.net/imagini-tulburatoare-la-vamasiret-sute-de-fugiati-ukraineni-asteptati-cu-gosi-calde-si-camioane-pline-cu-alimente-peste-4000- free-accommodation-offers_6273918.html
• Horsia, S. “Refugiat în România. Cum îi mai ajută oamenii și autoritățile pe ucraineni după un an de război/Refugee in Romania. How do people and authorities still help Ukrainians after a year of war” Europa Liberă/ Europa Liberă Romania [online]. Available at: https://romania.europalibera.org/
a/refugiati-ucraina-romania/32294614.html
• Vasile, M. Controverse după implementarea noii formule de acordare a burselor de merit. Elevi cu medii de 1.50 ajung să fie “răsplătiți” pentru notele slabe/Controversies after the implementation of the new formula for awarding merit scholarships. Students with averages of 1.50 end up being “rewarded” for poor grades”, euronews.ROMANIA, [online]. Available at: https://www.euronews.ro/articole/un-elev-de-la-o-scoala-din-prahova-a-luat-bursade-merit-cu-media-4-59
• https://avp.ro/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Pozitia-AvP-fata-de-Ordinul-5379-2022.pdf
• https://avp.ro/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Pozitia-AvP-fata-de-Ordinul-5379-2022.pdf
• https://avp.ro/index.php/exceptii-de-neconstitutionalitate-2020/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/exceptii-de-neconstitutionalitate-2021/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/recomandari-2020/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/recomandari-2021/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/recomandari-2022/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/2020/12/23/postare-4/
• https://avp.ro/index.php/2022/10/03/monitorizarea-respectarii-drepturilor-refugiatilor-din-ukraina/
• https://www.ccr.ro/decizii-covid-19/
• https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandemia_de_COVID-19
• https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Recession
• https://www.trt.net.tr/romana/covid19
• https://www.webdex.ro/definitia-criza-definitie-dex
• https://www.zf.ro/romania-la-raport/cum-de-a-ajuns-guvernul-luiemil-boc-sa-taie-15-din-pensii-si-25-din-salariile- from-the-public-system-6415393 .